Tom Mihalek/Reuters
Tom Mihalek/Reuters
Jeanne Noonan/ For New York Daily News
Todd Maisel, New York Daily News/New York Daily News
Jefferson Siegel/For Ny Daily News
Robert Nickelsberg/Getty Images
Joe Marino For New York Daily News
Bruce Bennett/Getty Images
Charles Sykes/Ap
Adrees Latif/Reuters
Andrew Burton/Getty Images
Debbie Egan-Chin/New York Daily News
Timothy A. Clary/Getty Images
Mario Tama/Getty Images
Ap Photo/Ana Andjelic
Lucas Jackson/Reuters
Ap Photo/Frank Franklin Ii
Mariela Lombard For New York Daily News
Mark Bonifacio/New York Daily News
Reuters/Mike Segar
Anthony Delmundo For New York Daily News
Bryan Smith For New York Daily News
Corey Sipkin/New York Daily News
Mariela Lombard For New York Daily News
Todd Maisel/New York Daily News
Mario Tama/Getty Images
Ron Antonelli/ New York Daily News
Seth Wenig/Ap
Stan Honda/Afp/Getty Images
Brendan Smialowskia/Getty Images
Reuters/Shannon Stapleton
Marcus Santos For New York Daily News
James Keivom/New York Daily News
Louis Lanzano/Ap
John Minchillo/Ap
Brendan Smalowski/Afp Photo/Getty Images
Charles Sykes/Ap
Jim Watson/Getty Images
Reuters/Carlo Allegri
Aaron Showalter For New York Daily News
Jeanne Noonan For New York Daily News
Joe Marino For New York Daily News
Ap Photo/Frank Franklin Ii
Craig Warga/New York Daily News
Anthony Delmundo For New York Daily News
Larry Downing/Reuters
Rex Features Via Ap Images
Mariela Lombard For New York Daily News
Nicholas Fevelo For New York Daily News
Craig Warga / New York Daily News
Andrew Burton/Getty Images
Lucas Jackson/Reuters
Usmc/Reuters
Carlo Allegri/Reuters
Ap Photo/Charles Sykes
Gary Hershorn/Reuters
Richard Harbus For New York Daily News
Ken Murray/New York Daily News
Todd Maisel/New York Daily News
Pearl Gabel For New York Daily News
Ap Photo/Metropolitan Transportation Authority Of The State Of N
Darren Mccollester/Getty Images
Adrees Latif/Reuters
Ron Antonelli/ New York Daily News
Lucas Jackson/Reuters
Joe Marino For New York Daily News
Reuters/Carlo Allegri
Anthony Delmundo For New York Daily News
Craig Warga / New York Daily News
Timothy A. Clary/Getty Images
Keith Bedford/Reuters
Lucas Jackson/Reuters
Bryan Smith/For New York Daily News
Reuters/Larry Downing
Brendan Smialowski/Afp/Getty Images
Lucas Jackson/Reuters
Seth Wenig/Ap
Keith Bedford/Reuters
Joe Marino For New York Daily News
Mark C. Olsen/Reuters
Jeanne Noonan For New York Daily News
Mariela Lombard For New York Daily News
Jeanne Noonan For New York Daily News
Mariela Lombard/For New York Daily News
Andrew Burton/New York Daily News
Frank Franklin Ii/Ap
Pearl Gabel For New York Daily News
Bryan Pace/New York Daily News
Todd Maisel/New York Daily News
Frank Franklin Ii/Ap
Mario Tama/Getty Images
Reuters/Carlo Allegri
Rosanne Salvatore/New York Daily News
Mario Tama/Getty Images
Howard Simmons/New York Daily News
Lucas Jackson/Reuters
Stan Honda/Getty Images
Mark C. Olsen/Reuters
Joe Marino For New York Daily News
Ap Photo/Pablo Martinez Monsivais
Anthony Delmundo For New York Daily News
David Handschuh/New York Daily News
Andrew Burton/Getty Images
Ron Antonelli/ New York Daily News
Jim Greenhill/Army National Guard/Reuters
Mark C. Olsen/Reuters
Adrees Latif/Reuters
More than five years after Hurricane Sandy badly damaged dozens of public housing developments, NYCHA has spent less than a quarter of the $3 billion it got to fix things up.
And as of Wednesday, only one of 33 developments receiving repair funds from the Federal Emergency Management Administration (FEMA) is finished.
The storm struck in October 2012, flooding developments from Far Rockaway, Queens, to Coney Island, Brooklyn, to up and down the East River in Manhattan.
FEMA awarded the huge Sandy grant in March 2015, and NYCHA said the agency began turning over funds that fall. As of Wednesday, NYCHA has spent just $730 million of that, or 24%.
Joy Sinderbrand, NYCHA Vice President of Recovery & Resilience, said every repair “is being done in a thoughtful and deliberate manner” to ensure the buildings will be able to withstand another storm.
To date construction has begun at 27 developments, but completion dates stretch into 2021 (Mayor de Blasio’s final year at City Hall). And NYCHA is still picking contractors for three more, with three others still in the design phase.
NYCHA Chairwoman Shola Olatoye, who’s been under fire for a wave of heating outages and failures in lead paint inspections, portrayed the progress to date as a model to be emulated nationally.
“Our Sandy recovery work shows that NYCHA can be a leader in rebuilding stronger, more resilient cities,” she said.
Councilmember Ritchie Torres, D-Bronx, a frequent NYCHA critic, was less complimentary: “Only NYHCA would celebrate a quarter of the mission accomplished. It’s an example of defining success downward.”
Public Advocate Letitia James, who has called for Olatoye to resign for falsely claiming NYCHA was performing required lead paint inspections, also questioned the pace of the Sandy renewal.
“There are serious questions surrounding why so little of the dedicated FEMA funds have been used and where exactly those funds have gone,” James said. “Five years after Sandy, there is still far too much that needs to be fixed and New Yorkers deserve better.”
At the Isaacs Houses on the Upper East Side, NYCHA has yet to pick a contractor to make the 636-unit development a few hundred feet from the East River storm-resistant.
Tenant Association President Rose Bergin said the authority initially told Isaacs residents that $33 million from FEMA was set aside for their development, but last summer they changed the amount to $19 million.
And last year contractors doing other repairs at Isaacs used a playground there as a staging area, making it useless for children to play in. They did that, she said, anticipating that the FEMA money would fix it up.
Since then, she says, she hasn’t seen a dime or heard anything about the progress of the FEMA fixup.
“They said, ‘When we put that list out, that was just an estimate’,” Bergin said. “They haven’t done nothing. They haven’t picked a contractor. They’re full of it.”